Pdf participant observation as a data collection method. This component supplies a dimension of information that is lacking in survey data. Introduction all methods involve observation, but participant observation is characterized by the extent to which its advocates insist on observation and interpretation of a situation, informed by an understanding of the situation from the point of view of the participants rather than the observer. Merits of participant observation participant observation is a very useful method of research and has the following merits. Advantages, disadvantages, and lessons learned from the middletown media studies time is a sort of river of passing events, and strong is its current. Discuss the merits and demerits of participant and. Observation, particularly participant observation, has been used in a variety of disciplines as a tool for collecting data about people, processes, and cultures in qualitative research. Advantages you know the situation is real and not artificially set up. Validity produces rich qualitative data which shows picture of how people really live. Research methods education participant observation disadvantages practical.
Observational research, advantages and disadvantages sage. Participant observation is closely related to the ethnographic method or ethnography, which. Disadvantages are the participant will change their routine because they are being observed. Although scientific controlled observation requires some technical skill of the researcher, still it is easier than other methods. This assignment of actually being involved in a participant observation activity has shown me some of the advantages and disadvantages of this form of research method. Give examples of the problems and pitfalls in doing observational research. Participant observation involves the observer being a member of the setting in which they are collecting data there are quite a few variations of this definition observation is normally associated with an ethnographic methodology more later but can be used as part of other research designs. Interviews, questionnaires and observation constantinos n. Participant observation is a research method which involves the researcher joining a group and looking at the members activities or daily lives. Data is collected and interpreted through the lenses of the observer. This approach enables a researcher to participate in a social group and observe people as well as the environment.
Advantages and disadvantages of ethnographic research advantages provides comprehensive perspective observes behaviors in their natural environments accounts for the complexity of group behaviors, reveal interrelationships among multifaceted dimensions of group interactions, and provide context for behaviors. Advantages and disadvantages of using participant observation 5. The history of participant observation as a method 4. A researcher is able to observe the real behaviour being very near to natural environment can note these which people cannot express or do not want to express and this cannot be done in nonparticipant observation. Advantages of overt observation, it is cheep, legal and you will not find anything that the participant does not want you to. Participant observation essay plan revisesociology.
Participant observation is a qualitative data collection methodology that provides rich descriptive information on human behaviors and experiences in a particular context. The collection of detailed field notes is key to successful nonparticipant observation. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages essay sample. Overt participant observation advantages they could modify their behaviour, this is often referred to as the hawthorne effect the researcher asking the questions may make the subjects more reflective about their own actions and attitudes, this can cause them to change. Qualitative descriptions generated by participant observation are used to formulate. A researcher is able to observe the real behaviour being very near to natural environment can note these which people cannot express or do not want to express and this cannot be done in non participant observation. Some of the examples of studies using the method of participant observation are.
The advantages and disadvantages of using qualitative eric. Although scientific controlled observation requires some technical skill of the researcher, still it is easier. Pdf observation is used in the social sciences as a method for collecting data about people, processes, and cultures. If the researcher has biases and expectations, they potentially affect this process.
Disadvantages can be very inaccurate if done poorly. Consider the accessibility of the populations and the venues in which you would like to observe them. The bobo doll experiment bandura 1961 reference iv a young girl hitting bobo a young boy pointing a gun at bobo bandura 1961 is a perfect example of a nonparticipant observation investigation. Observational research studies have been conducted with the consent of the human subjects under study using certain subjects as informants or. Aug 16, 2019 participant observation requires the researcher to be a subjective participant in the sense that they use knowledge gained through personal involvement with the research subjects to interact with and gain further access to the group. All of us see the world we live in through different eyes because of our environment, individual choices, and personalized influences. One of the most compelling examples of the value of participant observation in gaining insights that would be hard to capture through any other research method. The pros and cons of participant observation essay bartleby. Thus, interviews can be done face to face or by tele.
Generally, provides a big picture disadvantages observers can distort information results can change if the subject becomes aware. Both of these methodologies have their advantages and disadvantages. Nov 04, 2014 merits of participant observation participant observation is a very useful method of research and has the following merits. Useful for gaining an understanding of the physical, social, cultural, and economic contexts in which study participants live. The collection of detailed field notes is key to successful non participant observation. Advantages and disadvantages of structured observation. This post covers the theoretical, practical and ethical strengths and limitations of using overt and covert participant observation in social research. However, this only happens if the observation is covert. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages essays. Can observe things that may cause the behavior that you cannot do in the lab. What are the advantages and disadvantages of covert observation. Preparing for participant observation steps determine the purpose of the participant observation activity as related to the overall research objectives. Choose from 335 different sets of disadvantages of participant observation flashcards on quizlet. During participant observation, the researcher works to play two separate roles at the same time.
It is also easier to record information and observations if you do not are not participating, so you can record data more easily. It is favored by interpretivist sociologists as it acheives their main goals of validity especially if it is an unstructured observation. The success or failure of the research will hinge on such factors as the ability to fitin with the people being studied. Observation is a strategy that many qualitative researchers use to capture a comprehensive understanding of an event or phenomenon. An individual may delegated with creating consent forms for a particular. Exploring the advantages and disadvantages of qualitative data collection methods munshi samaduzzaman. While teacher observations have distinct advantages, the disadvantages are quite striking. Time consuming participant observation is often timeconsuming for an analyst. The advantages and disadvantages of the participant. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages free. What are the advantages of using participant observation in. Observation is probably the most common and the simplest method of data collection. This helps identify meaning as opposed to merely studying the behavior itself. Whites study of cornville social and athletic club and p.
Qualitative observational methods allow the researcher to capture the overt and subtle factors of the research setting. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages. Conducting observational research deakin university. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages essay. The advantages of qualitative observational methods synonym. Learn disadvantages of participant observation with free interactive flashcards. What are the advantages and disadvantages of the research.
Advantages and disadvantages of covert observation advantages of covert observation it does not disturb the normal behaviour of the group so there is higher validity it allows the observer to dig deeper into the groups behaviour it gives access to certain secret behavior of the. It may require resources, such as technical experts, who are not available. Each of the methods has their distinctive advantages and disadvantages which are discussed throughout the article. Mar 11, 2012 advantages of overt observation, it is cheep, legal and you will not find anything that the participant does not want you to. Participant observation is often timeconsuming for an analyst. The bobo doll experiment bandura 1961 reference iv a young girl hitting bobo a young boy pointing a gun at bobo bandura 1961 is a perfect example of a non participant observation investigation. Observational research, advantages and disadvantages. A disadvantage of participant observation is that a only a small sample can be from ant 2410 at florida state college at jacksonville. Advantages and limitations observation method for data collection. The advantages of qualitative observational methods.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Advantages and disadvantages participant observation. A disadvantage of participant observation is that a only a. More commonly, however, it is viewed positivistically as useful during the preliminary stages of scientific inquiry for exploration and description lazarsfeld, 1972. Skill and commitment participant observation requires agreat deal of skill and commitment from the researcher. Researchers are able to overcome the effects of these preconceptions by being aware they exist and looking out for them. Usually do when you have no idea about what is going on. Fifthly, qualitative research methods such as participantobservation, unstructured interviews, direct. The advantages and disadvantages of the participant observation research method in anthropology pages 3.
This chapter concerns all of these, explaining how to design and administer structured interview schedules, design and. What are the advantages and disadvantages of covert. Mar 31, 2016 participant observation is where the researcher joins in with the group being studied and observes their behaviour. Observer cannot always be present there are times when the analyst cannot be present because he or she does not know where and when an incident will occur. Exploring the advantages and disadvantages of qualitative. Source for information on non participant observation. To best evaluate a teacher, districts should use observation in conjunction with other sources of data. When it comes to a participant consent form, the content is all about the conditions of the activity the participant will be in. Although the collection of observational data yields subjective information and is therefore open to interpretation, it is sometimes both inevitable and.
This paper will concentrate more specifically on the advantages of such methodologies and highlights the sparse literature. An observational method 3 an observational method for time use research. It is important that the researcher build trust and develop empathy with participants, whilst simultaneously making sure to avoid overempathising with participants. Advantages and disadvantages of using participant observation. Participant observation and finally case study method. See factsheet 64 for details on covert participant.
Participant observation is where the researcher joins in with the group being studied and observes their behaviour. Disadvantages compared to participant observations. Observational research studies have been conducted with the consent of the human subjects under study using certain subjects as informants or without it covert. The participant is informed of advantages and disadvantages associated with the activity in question. Participant observation in participant observation, the researcher intervenes in the environment. In general, these data collection instruments fall into three broad categories. May 04, 2011 however, this only happens if the observation is covert. Deciding to use structured observation instruments 201. Also, behaviors remain relatively natural, thereby giving the measurements high external validity. May serve as a check against participants subjective reporting of what they believe and do. When a group knows that they are going to be observed by a stranger, they feel conscious, uncomfortable and therefore neutrality in their behaviour and activity is lost. What are the advantages of using participant observation. Source for information on nonparticipant observation. Covert participant observation describes a researcher becoming embedded in the group or organization that they are studying gephart, 2004, whilst the researcher conceals their true identity and purports to play some other role vinten, 1994, p.
Data sources indepth conversations researcher helps the participant to describe lived experiences without leading the discussion. At the end of the session i hoped that participants would be able to explain some advantages and disadvantages of observation methods, and define what is meant by unstructured versus structured. Participant observation advantages and disadvantages 8 august 2016 all methods involve observation, but participant observation is characterized by the extent to which its advocates insist on observation and interpretation of a situation, informed by an understanding of the situation from the point of view of the participants rather than the. They could modify their behaviour, this is often referred to as the hawthorne effect. The participant observation method, also known as ethnographic research, is when a sociologist actually becomes a part of the group they are studying in order to collect data and understand a social phenomenon or problem.
Participant observation essay plan assess the strengths of participant observation in social research 16 the main strength of using participant observation is that it usually yields extremely valid data compared to most, if not all, other research methods. If the observation is overt you are more at risk from the hawthorne effect as people know they are being. Participant observation as a data collection method. Observational research is a term that encompasses many different forms of qualitative inquiry, each of which deals with monitoring and noting conditions as they exist in the field, rather than constructing an experimental design. May 22, 2016 participant observation essay plan assess the strengths of participant observation in social research 16 the main strength of using participant observation is that it usually yields extremely valid data compared to most, if not all, other research methods. Can observe things where you cannot do experiments. Instead of just indicating that the research study was conducted in a thirdgrade classroom, observation allows the researcher to see and record how the study participants interact with the physical environment of the classroom. Advantages and disadvantages of covert observation by. Non participant observation can be overt or covert. Grounded theory grounded theory has been considered as the methodology commonly and frequently mentioned by. Participant observation and nonparticipant observation. The natural behaviour of the respondent can be studied by participant observation.
Advantages and disadvantages of participant observation. In the main body of this essay, this idea will be addressed by pointing out advantages and disadvantages of participant observation. Jan 07, 2015 preparing for participant observation steps determine the purpose of the participant observation activity as related to the overall research objectives. The results are filed away permanently in the teachers human resource file, and decisions such as tenure and promotions can be based on this information. Most commonly, this refers to inserting himselfherself as a member of a group, aimed at observing behavior that otherwise would not be accessible. Being a participant observer allows a social science researcher to observe behaviors and interactions in context, that is a naturalistic setting. This post covers the theoretical, practical and ethical strengths and limitations of using overt and covert participant observation in social.
1286 1203 309 195 1174 514 1609 79 611 1449 1078 50 1480 373 1180 522 320 1295 1005 1325 1385 1210 317 1377 552 487 131 1063 701 268 301 98 911 698 835 158